PERQS

Keeping vs. Canceling a Credit Card: Pros and Cons

Deciding how long to keep a credit card depends on multiple factors, including its impact on your credit score, fees, and overall financial goals. While keeping an account open is generally beneficial, there are circumstances where closing a card might make sense.

Summary

Deciding how long to keep a credit card depends on multiple factors, including its impact on your credit score, fees, and overall financial goals. While keeping an account open is generally beneficial, there are circumstances where closing a card might make sense.


💳 Should You Keep Your Credit Card Open?

Many credit cardholders wonder if they should keep a card indefinitely or close it when they stop using it. The answer isn't always straightforward. If a credit card remains in good standing and is regularly used, the issuer is unlikely to close it. However, canceling a card can negatively affect credit scores due to its impact on the credit utilization ratio, which accounts for 30% of a credit score. A closed credit card with a positive history can remain on your credit report for up to 10 years, but closing an old account may eventually lower the average age of your accounts.

One alternative to closing a credit card is a product change, which allows you to switch to another card offered by the same issuer. This option retains your account history while potentially offering better rewards or lower fees.

Takeaways:

• Keeping a credit card open can help maintain a strong credit score, especially if it has a long history.

• Closing a credit card can increase your credit utilization ratio, which may lower your score.

• A product change allows you to switch to a different card without affecting your credit score.

Key Terms

• Credit Utilization Ratio: The percentage of your total available credit that you’re currently using. A lower ratio is better for your credit score.

• Product Change: A switch to a different credit card offered by the same issuer, usually without affecting your credit history.


🚪 When Should You Close a Credit Card?

While keeping a card open is generally a good idea, there are valid reasons to close one. If a card has an annual fee but is no longer providing value, canceling it can save money. To minimize the credit score impact, it’s advisable to pay off other balances before closing a high-limit card. Additionally, if you have multiple low-limit cards that you rarely use, closing them can simplify account management and reduce the risk of fraud or identity theft.

Before canceling a card, make sure the balance is paid off and that any rewards have been redeemed. Otherwise, you might forfeit valuable points or miles.

Takeaways:

• Closing a credit card with an annual fee can be beneficial if you're not getting enough value from it.

• Canceling low-limit, unused credit cards can simplify financial management and reduce security risks.

• Always pay off balances and redeem rewards before closing a credit card.

Key Terms

• Annual Fee: A charge that some credit cards require for card membership, usually in exchange for rewards or perks.

• Credit Limit: The maximum amount you can charge on a credit card.


Conclusion

There’s no universal rule for how long you should keep a credit card. If you’re benefiting from your card, there’s no harm in keeping it indefinitely. However, if the card no longer meets your needs or costs you more than it’s worth, closing it might be a wise decision. Reviewing your credit cards annually can help ensure you’re using the best options available.